CCertihomes
2386 Route 5, Sheridan, NY 14136

$995,000

5 beds 4 baths 4,192 sqft Built 1991150 days on marketActive

About this home

This custom built 5bd/3.5 bath home in Eagle Bay is truly one of a kind. Enter the 2 story foyer adorned by a custom oak floating staircase, a quiet sitting area and formal living room. Step up to your right and be prepared for the spectacular open concept design featuring cathedral ceilings and a wall of windows. The kitchen features custom Amish cabinets, quartz countertops, and flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, breakfast bar, family room with woodburning fireplace and great room separated only by the second story balcony. Just off the dining room you will also find a half bath and the primary suite complete with sitting area, walk-in closet, built in wardrobe and full bath. On the opposite side of the home you will find an additional first floor bedroom with sliding door to patio, a full bath and laundry room. The second floor features a small loft, 3 bedrooms, a full bath, access to the floating balcony and outdoor balcony. A sliding door from the great room leads to an oversized patio and from the dining room to a gazebo, inground pool, lighthouse and lush floral gardens. With over 200' of unobstructed Lake Erie views, this property is a true gem!

Affordability — calculate your monthly payment

Adjust your budget to see what's left after housing, utilities and transportation. Numbers below assume a 5% down, 30YrJumbo at 4% APR.

Your estimated payment
$7,777/mo

Real estate (PITI + HOA + PMI)
$6,872
Principal + interest$4,513
Property tax + insurance$1,986
PMI / 2nd mortgage$373
Utilities
$2,373
Heating + cooling$1,037
Internet + TV + phone$133
Water + sewer + garbage$58
Transportation
$0
Other (entertainment)
$133
$7,777/mo TLC
Budget$8,277/mo
Remaining after TLC$500/mo
Purchase price
$995,000
Down payment
$49,750 (5%)
Loan amount
$945,250
APR
4%

Quick facts

Type
SingleFamilyResidence
Style
Mediterranean, TwoStory
Year built
1991
Lot size
2.81 ac
Stories
2
Heating
Gas, Baseboard
Cooling
Water
Connected, Public
HOA
Annual tax
$11,090
MLS #
B1593926
County
Chautauqua

At a glance

Fireplace
Basement
Garage (2)
Waterfront

Home features

Appliances
BuiltInRangeBuiltInOvenDoubleOvenDishwasherElectricCooktopExhaustFanElectricOvenElectricRangeDisposalGasWaterHeaterRefrigeratorRangeHood
Interior
BreakfastBarCeilingFansCathedralCeilingsSeparateFormalDiningRoomEntranceFoyerEatInKitchenSeparateFormalLivingRoomGraniteCountersGreatRoomHotTubSpaKitchenIslandPantryPullDownAtticStairsSlidingGlassDoorsBedroomOnMainLevelBathInPrimaryBedroomMainLevelPrimaryPrimarySuite
Exterior
BlacktopDrivewayBalconyConcreteDrivewayFencePoolPatioPrivateYardSeeRemarks
Parking
AttachedGarage
Pool
InGround
Flooring
Carpet, CeramicTile, Hardwood, Tile, Varies, Vinyl
Roof
Asphalt
Sewer
SepticTank

Lot features

IrregularLot, Secluded

Neighborhood — 14136

MetricThis ZIPCountyUSA
Population4,16519,351,094299,088,112
Population Change Since1990-4.00%8.00%20.00%
Population Density165395
Male1,9879,381,926147,432,321
Female2,1789,969,168151,655,844
Never Married7234,946,39163,775,926
Married1,8497,166,701123,120,365
Separated1191,159,67312,639,686
Widowed3921,110,24515,467,586
Divorced3271,210,44823,075,029
Number Of House Hold1,5307,102,016111,826,380
Average House Hold Size2.612.642.60
Medial Age40.3836.5335.46
Median House Hold Income$38,922$49,847$48,276
Average House Hold Income$47,286$70,032$63,629
P C I$18,033$26,569$24,529
M D I$34,087$42,210$41,133
A T H E$42,134$54,185$50,898
S T R8.00%4.00%
W C J74.11%81.55%77.74%
(Zip) Code
14136

Data via Certihomes neighborhood index. Comparisons across this ZIP, county and the United States.

Map & walkability

Open in Google Maps →

Listing information last refreshed 3/20/2025. Provided courtesy of HUNT Real Estate Corporation via Buffalo MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.