$1,289,000
About this home
Welcome to The Garnsey on Cayuga Lake — a truly exceptional lakefront retreat that blends timeless charm with modern luxury. Originally rich in history, this stunning property was completely reimagined and rebuilt from the ground up in 2019. Set on over an acre of beautifully maintained grounds with more than 130 feet of direct lake frontage, this estate boasts great outdoor living spaces, a dock, and panoramic views of Cayuga Lake that stretch for miles. Spanning over 3, 800 square feet of total living space, including an 850-square-foot finished bonus area above the garage, this home is designed with lifestyle and functionality in mind. Step inside through the side entry and you’ll be welcomed by a spacious mudroom and laundry area—complete with built-in cabinetry and a convenient dog-wash station—ideal for cleaning up after a day on the water or exploring the nearby Finger Lakes trails. The heart of the home is the chef’s kitchen, featuring a large custom island, high-end appliances, and ample storage. It flows seamlessly into the formal dining room, which offers plenty of space for entertaining large groups or intimate dinners with friends and family. Just off the kitchen, the center hall entry leads to a spacious living room and out to the expansive covered front porch, where you’ll enjoy unobstructed views of the lake from sunrise to sunset. The main-floor primary bedroom is a peaceful retreat, complete with dramatic vaulted ceilings and a picturesque picture window framing lake views. Upstairs, you'll find two generously sized guest bedrooms, both with walk-in closets, along with a beautifully appointed full bathroom. The primary suite upstairs is a true sanctuary, boasting a luxurious spa-like bathroom with double vanity, tiled walk-in shower, and a massive walk-in closet. From the second-floor covered balcony, you can enjoy elevated views of the lake and soak in the serenity of waterfront living. Whether you're seeking a year-round residence, a seasonal escape, or a luxury short-term rental opportunity, The Garnsey on Cayuga Lake offers it all—privacy, elegance, and prime access to the best the Finger Lakes have to offer. Offered fully furnished!
Affordability — calculate your monthly payment
Adjust your budget to see what's left after housing, utilities and transportation. Numbers below assume a 5% down, 30YrJumbo at 4% APR.
- Real estate (PITI + HOA + PMI)
- $8,397
- Utilities
- $2,127
- Transportation
- $0
- Other (entertainment)
- $133
Quick facts
At a glance
Home features
Lot features
Rectangular, RectangularLot
Neighborhood — 13148
| Metric | This ZIP | County | USA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 9,829 | 19,351,094 | 299,088,112 |
| Population Change Since1990 | -2.00% | 8.00% | 20.00% |
| Population Density | 150 | 395 | — |
| Male | 5,076 | 9,381,926 | 147,432,321 |
| Female | 4,753 | 9,969,168 | 151,655,844 |
| Never Married | 2,142 | 4,946,391 | 63,775,926 |
| Married | 4,305 | 7,166,701 | 123,120,365 |
| Separated | 471 | 1,159,673 | 12,639,686 |
| Widowed | 604 | 1,110,245 | 15,467,586 |
| Divorced | 705 | 1,210,448 | 23,075,029 |
| Number Of House Hold | 3,548 | 7,102,016 | 111,826,380 |
| Average House Hold Size | 2.58 | 2.64 | 2.60 |
| Medial Age | 37.07 | 36.53 | 35.46 |
| Median House Hold Income | $42,350 | $49,847 | $48,276 |
| Average House Hold Income | $50,455 | $70,032 | $63,629 |
| P C I | $19,937 | $26,569 | $24,529 |
| M D I | $36,796 | $42,210 | $41,133 |
| A T H E | $43,986 | $54,185 | $50,898 |
| S T R | 8.00% | 4.00% | — |
| W C J | 85.29% | 81.55% | 77.74% |
Data via Certihomes neighborhood index. Comparisons across this ZIP, county and the United States.
Map & walkability
Open in Google Maps →Listing information last refreshed 6/10/2025. Provided courtesy of Century 21 Steve Davoli RE via Buffalo MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.