CCertihomes
51 Seneca Street, Starkey, NY 14837

$275,000

6 beds 2 baths 3,672 sqft Built 18828 days on marketActive

About this home

1882 Victorian with 5-6 bedrooms in excellent condition. This home showcases so much history with gorgeous chandeliers, hardwood floors, pocket doors, stained glass, fireplace in the front formal parlor. There's so much to see that only a private showing will allow someone to take it all in. Relax in the backyard from the gazebo surrounded by flower gardens. It's only a short walk to the business district and even closer to the school. Located in the middle of the Finger Lakes it's only a short drive to area wineries, great restaurants on the lake, beaches, Watkins Glen International Raceway, grape vineyards and State Parks. Taxes based on 2024 assessment, the new assessment is $240, 000.

Affordability — calculate your monthly payment

Adjust your budget to see what's left after housing, utilities and transportation. Numbers below assume a 5% down, 30YrFixed at 7.15% APR.

Your estimated payment
$3,626/mo

Real estate (PITI + HOA + PMI)
$2,597
Principal + interest$1,765
Property tax + insurance$729
PMI / 2nd mortgage$103
Utilities
$2,071
Heating + cooling$881
Internet + TV + phone$143
Water + sewer + garbage$58
Transportation
$0
Other (entertainment)
$143
$3,626/mo TLC
Budget$5,000/mo
Remaining after TLC$1,374/mo
Purchase price
$275,000
Down payment
$13,750 (5%)
Loan amount
$261,250
APR
7.15%

Quick facts

Type
SingleFamilyResidence
Style
Victorian
Year built
1882
Lot size
0.3489 ac
Stories
2
Heating
Gas, ForcedAir
Cooling
Water
Connected, Public
HOA
Annual tax
$3,946
MLS #
R1623542
County
Yates

At a glance

Fireplace
Basement
Garage (1)

Home features

Appliances
DryerDishwasherGasOvenGasRangeGasWaterHeaterRefrigeratorWasher
Interior
CeilingFansDenSeparateFormalDiningRoomEntranceFoyerEatInKitchenSeparateFormalLivingRoomCountryKitchenNaturalWoodworkWindowTreatmentsBedroomOnMainLevel
Exterior
FullyFencedFenceGravelDriveway
Parking
AttachedGarageGarageDoorOpener
Flooring
Carpet, Hardwood, Tile, Varies
Roof
Asphalt, Shingle
Sewer
Connected

Lot features

Rectangular, RectangularLot, ResidentialLot

Neighborhood — 14837

MetricThis ZIPCountyUSA
Population3,92019,351,094299,088,112
Population Change Since19903.00%8.00%20.00%
Population Density50395
Male1,9169,381,926147,432,321
Female2,0049,969,168151,655,844
Never Married6804,946,39163,775,926
Married1,8247,166,701123,120,365
Separated1211,159,67312,639,686
Widowed2671,110,24515,467,586
Divorced3241,210,44823,075,029
Number Of House Hold1,4607,102,016111,826,380
Average House Hold Size2.602.642.60
Medial Age42.1436.5335.46
Median House Hold Income$37,522$49,847$48,276
Average House Hold Income$51,587$70,032$63,629
P C I$19,676$26,569$24,529
M D I$32,897$42,210$41,133
A T H E$44,574$54,185$50,898
S T R8.00%4.00%
W C J79.58%81.55%77.74%
(Zip) Code
14837

Data via Certihomes neighborhood index. Comparisons across this ZIP, county and the United States.

Map & walkability

Open in Google Maps →

Listing information last refreshed 7/17/2025. Provided courtesy of Keuka Lake & Land Realty via Buffalo MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.