CCertihomes
5736 Plum Brook Road, Great Valley, NY 14741

$375,000

4 beds 2 baths 2,016 sqft Built 19912 days on marketActive

About this home

Nestled on 5 picturesque acres just five minutes from the charming Village of Ellicottville and the slopes of Holiday Valley Resort and HoliMont, this inviting country Cape Cod offers the perfect blend of rural tranquility and year-round recreation. Featuring four spacious bedrooms and two full bathrooms, the home combines classic charm with comfortable living spaces ideal for gathering with family and friends. An expansive deck overlooks the surrounding hills and in winter, the view opens up for miles. A standout feature is the impressive detached garage/barn, complete with a 2-bay garage, first floor hobby room, and an insulated, heated workshop on the second level—perfect for hobbies, projects, or additional storage. Surrounded by rolling fields, mountains, and a peaceful, private setting, yet close to one of Western New York’s premier four-season destinations, this property is a rare find for those seeking both serenity and convenience. Whether you envision it as a primary residence, vacation getaway, or hobby farm, this country retreat is ready to welcome you home. Ask ChatGPT

Affordability — calculate your monthly payment

Adjust your budget to see what's left after housing, utilities and transportation. Numbers below assume a 5% down, 30YrFixed at 7.15% APR.

Your estimated payment
$4,026/mo

Real estate (PITI + HOA + PMI)
$3,330
Principal + interest$2,406
Property tax + insurance$783
PMI / 2nd mortgage$141
Utilities
$1,497
Heating + cooling$602
Internet + TV + phone$127
Water + sewer + garbage$58
Transportation
$0
Other (entertainment)
$127
$4,026/mo TLC
Budget$5,000/mo
Remaining after TLC$974/mo
Purchase price
$375,000
Down payment
$18,750 (5%)
Loan amount
$356,250
APR
7.15%

Quick facts

Type
SingleFamilyResidence
Style
CapeCod
Year built
1991
Lot size
4.9 ac
Stories
2
Heating
Electric, Propane, Baseboard, HotWater
Cooling
Water
Well
HOA
Annual tax
$4,372
MLS #
B1629292
County
Cattaraugus

At a glance

Basement
Garage (2)

Home features

Appliances
DryerDishwasherGasOvenGasRangeMicrowavePropaneWaterHeaterRefrigeratorWasher
Interior
BreakfastBarCeilingFansDiningAreaEntranceFoyerSeparateFormalLivingRoomLivingDiningRoomMainLevelPrimaryWorkshop
Exterior
GravelDrivewayPropaneTankLeased
Parking
DetachedGarageHeatedGarageStorageWorkshopInGarageCircularDriveway
Flooring
Carpet, Tile, Varies
Roof
Asphalt
Sewer
SepticTank

Lot features

IrregularLot, RuralLot, Secluded

Neighborhood — 14741

MetricThis ZIPCountyUSA
Population1,71719,351,094299,088,112
Population Change Since19905.00%8.00%20.00%
Population Density28395
Male8729,381,926147,432,321
Female8459,969,168151,655,844
Never Married3324,946,39163,775,926
Married7847,166,701123,120,365
Separated701,159,67312,639,686
Widowed1061,110,24515,467,586
Divorced1541,210,44823,075,029
Number Of House Hold6727,102,016111,826,380
Average House Hold Size2.522.642.60
Medial Age42.4636.5335.46
Median House Hold Income$42,696$49,847$48,276
Average House Hold Income$51,989$70,032$63,629
P C I$20,957$26,569$24,529
M D I$36,970$42,210$41,133
A T H E$44,865$54,185$50,898
S T R8.00%4.00%
W C J75.11%81.55%77.74%
(Zip) Code
14741

Data via Certihomes neighborhood index. Comparisons across this ZIP, county and the United States.

Map & walkability

Open in Google Maps →

Listing information last refreshed 8/8/2025. Provided courtesy of ERA Team VP Real Estate via Buffalo MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.