CCertihomes
419 Cayuga Heights Road, Ithaca Town, NY 14850

$798,500

4 beds 3 baths 2,495 sqft Built 19200 days on marketActive

About this home

This distinguished 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath Tudor is a rare find, offering the perfect marriage of historic character and sophisticated modern updates. Nestled on an expansive lot extending all the way to Upland Road, the property provides both privacy and convenience. Outdoor spaces are thoughtfully designed for relaxation and connection, featuring a classic stone patio ideal for entertaining, a fully fenced backyard for security and peace of mind with a charming private path with footbridge creating direct access to Cayuga Heights Elementary. Inside, timeless architectural details blend seamlessly with contemporary upgrades. The first floor showcases a beautifully remodeled kitchen, artfully designed to balance function and style, and a tastefully updated half bath. A formal dining room sets the stage for elegant gatherings, while the spacious living room, centered around a stately wood-burning fireplace, exudes warmth and comfort. Also on this level is a versatile office/family room/flex space with its own private entrance from the backyard. The second floor is anchored by a remarkable primary suite, where luxury meets intimacy. A two-sided gas fireplace creates a cozy ambiance between the bedroom and its adjoining sitting room or office. Dual walk-in closets provide generous storage, while the remodeled tiled bath offers a true spa-like retreat with a soaking tub, refined finishes, and exceptional attention to detail. Two additional bedrooms complete this level, including one with a fully renovated ensuite full bath. On the third floor, a renovated bedroom with custom built-ins, a skylight, and ample storage delivers both charm and functionality. The lower level adds to the home’s versatility, offering laundry, wine cellar, storage, a one-car garage, and a dedicated workspace. From its curated outdoor spaces with a free library on the backside of the property (Upland Rd.) to its sophisticated interior finishes, this home delivers a rare blend of elegance, comfort, and convenience in one of Cayuga Heights’ most sought-after locations.

Affordability — calculate your monthly payment

Adjust your budget to see what's left after housing, utilities and transportation. Numbers below assume a 5% down, 30YrJumbo at 4% APR.

Your estimated payment
$6,843/mo

Real estate (PITI + HOA + PMI)
$6,216
Principal + interest$3,622
Property tax + insurance$2,295
PMI / 2nd mortgage$299
Utilities
$1,664
Heating + cooling$680
Internet + TV + phone$138
Water + sewer + garbage$58
Transportation
$0
Other (entertainment)
$138
$6,843/mo TLC
Budget$7,343/mo
Remaining after TLC$500/mo
Purchase price
$798,500
Down payment
$39,925 (5%)
Loan amount
$758,575
APR
4%

Quick facts

Type
SingleFamilyResidence
Style
HistoricAntique, TwoStory, Tudor
Year built
1920
Lot size
0.5785 ac
Stories
2
Heating
Ductless, Electric, Gas, HeatPump, Zoned, ForcedAir
Cooling
Ductless, HeatPump, Zoned
Water
Connected, Public
HOA
Annual tax
$17,750
MLS #
S1630088
County
Tompkins

At a glance

Air conditioning
Fireplace
Basement
Garage (1)

Home features

Appliances
DryerDishwasherExhaustFanElectricOvenElectricRangeElectricWaterHeaterGasCooktopGasWaterHeaterMicrowaveRefrigeratorRangeHoodWineCoolerWasher
Interior
AtticDenSeparateFormalDiningRoomEntranceFoyerEatInKitchenSeparateFormalLivingRoomGraniteCountersKitchenIslandBathInPrimaryBedroomProgrammableThermostat
Exterior
AwningsBlacktopDrivewayBarbecueFullyFencedPatio
Community
TrailsPaths
Parking
AttachedUndergroundGarageDrivewayGarageDoorOpener
Flooring
Carpet, Hardwood, LuxuryVinyl, Tile, Varies
Roof
Asphalt
Sewer
Connected

Lot features

Agricultural, AdjacentToPublicLand, Rectangular, RectangularLot

Neighborhood — 14850

MetricThis ZIPCountyUSA
Population59,21319,351,094299,088,112
Population Change Since19906.00%8.00%20.00%
Population Density470395
Male29,6919,381,926147,432,321
Female29,5229,969,168151,655,844
Never Married28,2934,946,39163,775,926
Married15,0047,166,701123,120,365
Separated4,7011,159,67312,639,686
Widowed2,1131,110,24515,467,586
Divorced3,0161,210,44823,075,029
Number Of House Hold20,2577,102,016111,826,380
Average House Hold Size2.322.642.60
Medial Age27.6336.5335.46
Median House Hold Income$36,430$49,847$48,276
Average House Hold Income$55,345$70,032$63,629
P C I$20,447$26,569$24,529
M D I$32,060$42,210$41,133
A T H E$46,512$54,185$50,898
S T R8.00%4.00%
W C J80.69%81.55%77.74%
(Zip) Code
14850

Data via Certihomes neighborhood index. Comparisons across this ZIP, county and the United States.

Map & walkability

Open in Google Maps →

Listing information last refreshed 8/14/2025. Provided courtesy of Acropolis Realty Group LLC via Buffalo MLS. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.